Wednesday, February 8, 2023
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
Parliamentobserver
  • Ecology
  • Economy
  • Healthcare
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Business
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
Parliamentobserver
Home Economy

There Is No Such Thing As Wage-Driven Inflation

Dennis Rogers by Dennis Rogers
September 29, 2022
in Economy
0
There Is No Such Thing As Wage-Driven Inflation
0
SHARES
11
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Few know the name of Walter Heller, one of the first Chairs of the Council of Economic Advisers, and an adviser to President Kennedy. In 1968, however, he was a giant in economics who published in all the top journals. Fresh from his years in the Kennedy White House, he was invited to debate the relative importance of fiscal and monetary policy with another giant in economics, Milton Friedman, in a small book published by W.W. Norton & Company. Rarely do such debates interest more than a few thousand individuals. This is an exception, as a decade later PBS invited Heller and Friedman to debate their views on inflation. 

Related posts

Biden could reduce inflation, mitigate a recession, and strengthen democracy with a new EU-US trade agreement

Biden could reduce inflation, mitigate a recession, and strengthen democracy with a new EU-US trade agreement

September 29, 2022
Recent trends in global value chains and beyond

Recent trends in global value chains and beyond

September 29, 2022

The debate was an occasion to rehash points they had made in the book, with the advantages of an extra decade of development in theory, observations, and economic methods. This ended up being not only an immensely civilized exchange, a real departure from what we are now accustomed to, but also one that communicated high-quality economics ideas to the public. 

There is a key moment in that debate that is particularly important for present macroeconomic discussions. At one point, Walter Heller invoked the idea of wage-push inflation. The concept is simple enough: If unions or other forces push wages up, prices will go up. Friedman pounced on this statement, arguing that it is tautological. After all, a wage is a price. Saying that rising prices cause rising prices is logically circular. 

Friedman’s pouncing on Heller has, unfortunately, had no effect on American journalists. News shows and economic commentators still repeat variants of the claim made by Heller: Rising wages will contribute to inflation. Pick any news channel on any day and you are bound to hear the term “wage-driven inflation.” 

For that reason, and because repetition is sometimes necessary, Friedman’s case from 1978 must be reiterated in order to reduce the likelihood of this nonsensical claim being repeated in the media. 

To be sure, if you mandate higher wages without changing labor productivity, prices will rise. This post hoc ergo propter hoc argument is true. However, it is deceptively true. Mandating rising wages when productivity fails to increase leads to lower output. This is what causes prices to go up. The rising prices in this case are a symptom of fewer goods being produced. 

In the consumer price index (CPI), this shows up as inflation. However, anyone who inspects the CPI more closely will find that the magnitude of the price increases will depend on the extent of the fall of output sold to consumers. Capital-intensive industries, for example, will have smaller price increases than labor-intensive industries after they reduce their output because of the wage hike. 

Contrast this with another instance when prices rise: an expansion of the money supply. If a central bank puts more money in circulation, the inherent productivity of economic agents is unchanged. If productivity is unchanged, inflation is only reflecting the greater abundance of money. The new money could enter the economy unevenly, such that output prices and wages are also bid up unevenly (economists speak of rigidities). If some wages increase before some other wages and other prices, it may precipitate some increases in demand by households and prices for other goods will increase. However, this is a symptom of inflation induced by the change in the money. It is not the cause. In other words, it is only a mirage caused by the messy process of adjusting to changes in the money supply. 

Not making the distinction between these two cases is logically dangerous. This danger is most visible when discussing the effects of certain public policy. The Biden administration, for example, has pushed for many pro-union labor policies in order to drive up wages. Many conservatives have responded by arguing that this will push wages and prices in turn. Many economists, notably Albert Rees as early as the 1960s, have shown this is not the case. Unions may cause higher prices, but only inasmuch as firms must cut down on production through the firing of some workers. There may be a case to oppose such pro-union policies. It is on the grounds, however, of the effect on output rather than on the grounds of the effect on inflation rates. 

Let us hope that this additional iteration of a point made so often will sink in with journalists.

Previous Post

Then a Miracle Occurs…

Next Post

PRIVATE BLOG – The S&P 500 Prospects

Next Post
PRIVATE BLOG – The S&P 500 Prospects

PRIVATE BLOG – The S&P 500 Prospects

RECOMMENDED NEWS

Has Trump put the Republican party in danger of repeating the 2010 Senate race?

Has Trump put the Republican party in danger of repeating the 2010 Senate race?

6 months ago

Miscarriages Among Vaccinated Women

10 months ago
Will the Fed Reverse Course?

Will the Fed Reverse Course?

7 months ago
Sea level rise from climate change is threatening home septic systems and public health

Sea level rise from climate change is threatening home septic systems and public health

7 months ago

BROWSE BY CATEGORIES

  • Business
  • Ecology
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Healthcare
  • Politics

POPULAR NEWS

  • Klaus Schwab – The Most Dangerous Man in the World

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Ukraine Adopts WEF Proposals

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Dr. Robert Malone v WEF

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Trudeau’s Approval Rating Hits 12-Month Low

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Trudeau Backs Down After Banks Scream about Massive Withdrawals

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
Parliamentobserver

We bring you latest news about ecology, economy, healthcare, politics, education, business.

Recent News

  • Supporting Ukrainian Economy: #SpendWithUkraine Initiative Launched by Ukrainian Brands
  • Starting Up: A Look at the Most Interesting Websites for Entrepreneurs and Startups
  • The Role of Healthcare Advertising in Shaping Economic and Political Decisions

Category

  • Business
  • Ecology
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Healthcare
  • Politics

Recent News

Supporting Ukrainian Economy: #SpendWithUkraine Initiative Launched by Ukrainian Brands

Supporting Ukrainian Economy: #SpendWithUkraine Initiative Launched by Ukrainian Brands

February 6, 2023
Starting Up: A Look at the Most Interesting Websites for Entrepreneurs and Startups

Starting Up: A Look at the Most Interesting Websites for Entrepreneurs and Startups

January 18, 2023
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

© 2022 parliamentobserver.com Submit news release

No Result
View All Result
  • Ecology
  • Economy
  • Healthcare
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Business

© 2022 parliamentobserver.com Submit news release

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In