Thursday, March 30, 2023
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
Parliamentobserver
  • Ecology
  • Economy
  • Healthcare
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Business
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
Parliamentobserver
Home Economy

Smarter immigration policies could help alleviate the semiconductor shortage

Dennis Rogers by Dennis Rogers
September 29, 2022
in Economy
0
Smarter immigration policies could help alleviate the semiconductor shortage
0
SHARES
11
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

By Greg Wright, Dany Bahar, Ian Seyal

Related posts

Biden could reduce inflation, mitigate a recession, and strengthen democracy with a new EU-US trade agreement

Biden could reduce inflation, mitigate a recession, and strengthen democracy with a new EU-US trade agreement

September 29, 2022
Recent trends in global value chains and beyond

Recent trends in global value chains and beyond

September 29, 2022

From semiconductors to infant formula, U.S. consumers are facing acute shortages of essential goods. Ironically, both global and anti-global forces are behind this current disruption in supply chain. On the one hand, the shortage of infant formula reflects a highly protectionist trade regime that has led to dramatic concentration in production—only four domestic firms produce 90 percent of infant formula consumed in the U.S. On the other hand, the ongoing shortage of semiconductors highlights a similar outcome for the opposite reason: Until the recent U.S.-China trade war, decades of free trade in semiconductors have resulted in the concentration of chip production in Taiwan, South Korea, and China. While free trade has generated low prices and substantial productivity gains for consumers and workers, in both cases the concentration of industry production among a few firms in a handful of locations has exposed consumers to supply chain risks that are now coming to bear.

These hardships have pushed policymakers to consider new ways to ensure a more diverse and resilient supply chain for the most critical products, while still protecting the gains that the country receives from international trade. For semiconductors this means bringing some portion of the industry back to the U.S., which Congress is attempting to do through the CHIPS for America Act. This legislation creates a $52 billion tax credit for semiconductor equipment or manufacturing facility investments in the U.S., which intends to grow the domestic semiconductor industry on the coattails of the rising global demand for chips. Even though this funding is unlikely to be enough to make the industry competitive in leading-edge chips, it is a good start.

While tax credits may spur U.S. investment in equipment and facilities, firms still need to find thousands of workers with specialized skills to scale the industry—and they need to do so in time to compete with other countries’ efforts to do the same. Unfortunately, the long decline of the manufacturing labor force in the U.S. has eroded the country’s manufacturing base and redeveloping it could take years. But there is another possibility: Highly skilled immigrants could provide a substantial amount of this expertise immediately and could help retrain the domestic semiconductor workforce at the same time.

Figure 1. Immigrants already comprise a large share of talent in the semiconductor industry

Immigrants already comprise a large share of talent in the semiconductor industry Source: American Community Survey and Emsi-Burning-Glass

Crucially, immigrants already constitute a large presence in nearly all the occupations in the semiconductor industry, regardless of degree levels and skill requirements (Figure 1). Electrical, Electronic, and Electromechanical Assemblers, for instance, is the largest occupation in the sector at 14 percent of the total semiconductor labor force, and requires only a high school degree. The majority of workers within this occupation are also foreign-born, coming mainly from Mexico and Central America. At the other end of the education distribution are Electronics and Electrical Engineers, the third largest occupation, which typically requires an advanced degree. Again, half of these workers are foreign-born, with India and China being the largest origin countries.

As in the past, America’s path to global competitiveness in the semiconductor industry won’t arise solely from additional funding but will also require the country to import expertise through immigration.

Doubling or tripling the size of this workforce will be challenging if current congressional ambivalence about immigration policy continues. The new jobs that do not require a college degree can potentially be filled by native-born workers, but even this will require drawing thousands of workers out of other industries in some of the tightest labor markets in the country. For instance, new semiconductor fabrication plants may be built around Dallas, Texas and Chandler, Arizona, the locations of existing Texas Instruments and Intel manufacturing facilities. However, in both locations job postings per unemployed worker—a common measure of labor market tightness—are currently among the highest in the country, indicating a shallow pool of potential employees for the semiconductor industry.

Even in Ohio, where Intel has announced a $20 billion investment to build two new plants, the share of foreign-born workers in chip-making occupations (10 percent) is double the state’s average immigrant share (5 percent). Here, immigrant workers are drawn from a diverse set of countries, with nearly equal employment shares from India, Mexico, China, and Germany.

A starting point could be to retrain manufacturing workers who have recently lost their jobs and live in the same regions that also host semiconductor facilities. Table 1 shows that occupations in many declining industries have significant skills-overlap with the top semiconductor occupations. For instance, an astonishing 11,000 Sewing Machine Operators have lost their jobs over the past decade in Texas, California, Arizona, and Oregon, and these workers have substantial skills-overlap with both Semiconductor Processing Technicians as well as Electrical, Electronic, and Electromechanical Assemblers. But even this labor pool is unlikely to be enough. A more comprehensive solution to building a competitive semiconductor workforce would combine skills-retraining programs with an expansion of the H2-B visa program to allow more temporary, nonagricultural workers into the U.S. On this front, proposed legislation has gained some recent traction, but its passage remains highly uncertain.

Table 1. Some native-born workers in declining industries have the skills to staff a resurgent semiconductor industry

Some native-born workers in declining industries have the skills to staff a resurgent semiconductor industry

Note: SPT stands for Semiconductor Processing Technicians and EEE stands for Electrical, Electronic, and Electromechanical Assemblers. The figure focuses solely on industries and occupations that are in decline and that have a large presence in California, Texas, Oregon, or Arizona.
Source: EMSI-BurningGlass and Census American Community Survey

Jobs requiring a bachelor’s or advanced degree will prove even more difficult to fill. These jobs are almost entirely engineering positions that draw from the U.S. graduate school pipeline of foreign-born talent. In this case, a likely policy solutions will focus on expansion of H1-B temporary visa caps. Such solutions however face bipartisan resistance in Congress, as members (wrongly) worry that additional immigrants would suppress the wages of native U.S. workers.

In fact, expanded immigration policy is a necessary aspect of workforce development that can also benefit existing workers. The good news is that immigration inflows are nearly back to their pre-pandemic level. The bad news is that prospective engineering students are increasingly enrolling in undergraduate and graduate programs in other countries. Here, the nonpartisan desire for a more competitive semiconductor industry collides with the partisan politics of immigration.

As in the past, America’s path to global competitiveness in the semiconductor industry won’t arise solely from additional funding but will also require the country to import expertise through immigration. Any mix of policies that does not acknowledge this is doomed to fail.

Previous Post

The coming of age of sustainability disclosure: How do rules differ between the US and the EU?

Next Post

Audacity Needed in Natural Resource Governance:

Next Post
Audacity Needed in Natural Resource Governance:

Audacity Needed in Natural Resource Governance:

RECOMMENDED NEWS

Educating children to make the invisible, visible

Educating children to make the invisible, visible

1 year ago
Self-Identified “Compelling Interests” Are Not a License to Discriminate

Self-Identified “Compelling Interests” Are Not a License to Discriminate

9 months ago
Dismantling the ivory tower’s knowledge boundaries

Dismantling the ivory tower’s knowledge boundaries

11 months ago
Antitrust Crackdowns On Big Tech Won’t Help Consumers

Antitrust Crackdowns On Big Tech Won’t Help Consumers

12 months ago

BROWSE BY CATEGORIES

  • Business
  • Ecology
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Healthcare
  • Politics

POPULAR NEWS

  • Klaus Schwab – The Most Dangerous Man in the World

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Dr. Robert Malone v WEF

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Ukraine Adopts WEF Proposals

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Trudeau’s Approval Rating Hits 12-Month Low

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Trudeau Backs Down After Banks Scream about Massive Withdrawals

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
Parliamentobserver

We bring you latest news about ecology, economy, healthcare, politics, education, business.

Recent News

  • Supporting Ukrainian Economy: #SpendWithUkraine Initiative Launched by Ukrainian Brands
  • Starting Up: A Look at the Most Interesting Websites for Entrepreneurs and Startups
  • The Role of Healthcare Advertising in Shaping Economic and Political Decisions

Category

  • Business
  • Ecology
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Healthcare
  • Politics

Recent News

Supporting Ukrainian Economy: #SpendWithUkraine Initiative Launched by Ukrainian Brands

Supporting Ukrainian Economy: #SpendWithUkraine Initiative Launched by Ukrainian Brands

February 6, 2023
Starting Up: A Look at the Most Interesting Websites for Entrepreneurs and Startups

Starting Up: A Look at the Most Interesting Websites for Entrepreneurs and Startups

January 18, 2023
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

© 2022 parliamentobserver.com Submit news release

No Result
View All Result
  • Ecology
  • Economy
  • Healthcare
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Business

© 2022 parliamentobserver.com Submit news release

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In