Friday, May 23, 2025
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
Parliamentobserver
  • Ecology
  • Economy
  • Healthcare
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Business
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
Parliamentobserver
Home Healthcare

Lessons learned from housing policy during COVID-19

Dennis Rogers by Dennis Rogers
September 29, 2022
in Healthcare
0
Lessons learned from  housing policy during COVID-19
0
SHARES
11
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

By Kris Gerardi, Lauren Lambie-Hanson, Paul Willen, Laurie Goodman, Susan Wachter

Related posts

Eden Announces Extended Memorial Day Sale, Promoting Access to Metabolic Health Treatments

Eden Announces Extended Memorial Day Sale, Promoting Access to Metabolic Health Treatments

May 27, 2024
Top 5 Advantages of Staying in a Sober Living House

Top 5 Advantages of Staying in a Sober Living House

May 27, 2024

Lessons learned from housing policy during COVID-19

Recession Remedies

  • Chapter 05

01

Lessons learned from the breadth of economic policies during the pandemic

02

Lessons learned from expanded unemployment insurance during COVID-19

03

Lessons learned from Economic Impact Payments during COVID-19

04

Lessons learned from support to business during COVID-19

05

Lessons learned from housing policy during COVID-19

06

Lessons learned from support for the state and local sector during COVID-19

07

Lessons learned from the COVID-19 policy response and child well-being

08

Lessons learned from monetary and fiscal policy during COVID-19

09

Lessons learned from the use of nontraditional data during COVID-19

RECESSION REMEDIES

Lessons learned from housing policy
during COVID-19 Kris Gerardi, Lauren Lambie-Hanson, Paul Willen, Laurie Goodman, and Susan Wachter download the one-pager View the full chapter April 27, 2022 Illustration of houses

To aid American households experiencing distress during the COVID-19 pandemic, the U.S. government implemented a variety of programs and policies to aid renters and homeowners with mortgages. When the pandemic struck in early 2020, homeowners had substantially more equity in their homes than they did at the start of the Great Recession, leaving them in better financial shape than they were then and they enjoyed rising house prices. Renters were not so fortunate. Rents fell slightly below trend for a few months early in the pandemic and then accelerated.

Congress declared that homeowners who were experiencing hardship could postpone payments on their federally backed mortgage for up to 18 months with no penalty (known as forbearance). Many servicers of mortgages not backed by the federal government voluntarily did the same. In addition, mortgage rates fell, in part because of actions by the Federal Reserve, allowing many homeowners to reduce their monthly payments by refinancing their loans. For renters, Congress established the $46 billion Emergency Rental Assistance (ERA) program to help eligible households pay rent and utility bills. This program, coupled with federal, state, and local eviction moratoria, helped keep renters in their homes.

Evidence on housing policy

  • The national forbearance mandate, foreclosure moratorium, enhanced Unemployment Insurance (UI), and Economic Impact Payments (EIPs) aided in reducing financial distress for both owners and renters at the outset of the pandemic and prevented longer-run problems in mortgage and housing markets.
  • Over 80 percent of borrowers who missed a mortgage payment in the first three months of the pandemic enrolled in forbearance. Although minority mortgage borrowers were much more likely to experience distress and miss mortgage payments, conditional on missing payments, forbearance uptake was similar across racial and ethnic lines.
  • Low interest rates led to a wave of refinancing, but fewer Black borrowers benefited from refinancing than white borrowers.
  • The share of renters behind on rental payments has been above 2017 levels since 2020. Renter households who missed a rental payment were more likely to be lower-income households and were disproportionately minority households. Missed payments were most common among households who were struggling prior to the pandemic. The erratic rollout of the ERA, which was administered at the local level, prevented timely or easy access to these funds.
  • Eviction moratoria resulted in a redirection of scarce household resources to immediate consumption needs and likely prevented homelessness. The decline in evictions during the pandemic is not solely the result of the eviction moratorium. The decline may also reflect the impact of ERA, greater access to legal aid, the impact of eviction diversion programs, and income replacement for households.

Figure 1

Lessons learned from housing policy during COVID-19

Generous income replacement may be sufficient to support renters and homeowners if policymakers are concerned only with the incremental effect of the recession on those who were employed in the formal market before the recession. For renter households who were housing insecure before the pandemic, many without formal labor force attachment, this income replacement, the eviction moratorium and the ERA helped compensate for losses associated with the pandemic. However, these programs did not address the longstanding problems of this segment of the population which were worsened by pandemic.

Low interest rates led to a wave of refinancing, but fewer Black borrowers benefited from refinancing than white borrowers.

Unlike the Home Affordable Modification Program implemented during the Great Recession, enrolling in forbearance required zero documentation on the part of borrowers. But it is unclear if it would be as effective in a future crisis as the state of the pre-pandemic housing and mortgage markets and the dynamic of the pandemic were set up almost perfectly for forbearance to be effective: the rapid labor market recovery meant that most borrowers only needed a few months of assistance, the majority of outstanding mortgage debt was insured by the U.S. government, and the housing market was exceptionally healthy.

The decline in mortgage interest rates had more modest effects: most borrowers experiencing pandemic-related financial distress were less likely to refinance. To ensure that the benefits of lower mortgage rates reach a broader set of borrowers in future downturns, one could develop and market alternative mortgage products that automatically lower payments when rates decline as well as support more widespread adoption of streamlined refinance programs that do not require employment or income verification.

While the eviction moratorium did put a substantial dent in the number of filings where these data can be tracked, an eviction moratorium alone is not a long-run solution. The tenant still owes the money and may not have the resources to pay. Eviction moratoriums have negative externalities for landlords and are second best relative to ERA. A successful ERA program could keep renter delinquency rates from rising during recessions and in their aftermath. Such a program must be streamlined, with a simple application, minimal documentation, and clear eligibility rules, like the successful forbearance program.

Recession Remedies home Next Chapter

For more information or to speak with the authors, contact:

Marie Wilken

202-540-7738

[email protected]

Hamilton Project logo Hutchins Center logo

About the Authors

Kris Gerardi

Kris Gerardi

Financial Economist and Senior Policy Adviser – Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta

Lauren Lambie-Hanson

Lauren Lambie-Hanson

Senior Advisor and Research Fellow – Consumer Finance Institute, Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia

Paul Willen

Paul Willen

Senior Economist and Policy Advisor – Federal Reserve Bank of Boston

Laurie Goodman

Laurie Goodman

Vice President of Housing Finance Policy – Urban Institute

Susan Wachter

Susan Wachter

Albert Sussman Professor of Real Estate – The Wharton School, The University of Pennsylvania

© 2022 The Brookings Institution

  • Contact
  • Media Relations
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
Previous Post

Lessons learned from support for the state and local sector during COVID-19

Next Post

Introducing Recession Remedies, a podcast about lessons learned from the economic policy response to COVID-19

Next Post
Introducing Recession Remedies, a podcast about lessons learned from the economic policy response to COVID-19

Introducing Recession Remedies, a podcast about lessons learned from the economic policy response to COVID-19

RECOMMENDED NEWS

The economic significance of intra-African trade—getting the narrative right

The economic significance of intra-African trade—getting the narrative right

3 years ago
Beware of Fuel Theft

Beware of Fuel Theft

3 years ago
Reading: Feeding the Mind and Soul

Reading: Feeding the Mind and Soul

3 years ago
PRIVATE BLOG – Gold & War & Gold-Backed Ruble

PRIVATE BLOG – Gold & War & Gold-Backed Ruble

3 years ago

BROWSE BY CATEGORIES

  • Business
  • Ecology
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Healthcare
  • Politics
  • Uncategorized

POPULAR NEWS

  • Klaus Schwab – The Most Dangerous Man in the World

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Dr. Robert Malone v WEF

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Ukraine Adopts WEF Proposals

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Trudeau Backs Down After Banks Scream about Massive Withdrawals

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Trudeau’s Approval Rating Hits 12-Month Low

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
Parliamentobserver

We bring you latest news about ecology, economy, healthcare, politics, education, business.

Recent News

  • FTC Cracks Down on Hidden Charges and “Junk Fees” in New Proposal
  • Eden Announces Extended Memorial Day Sale, Promoting Access to Metabolic Health Treatments
  • Top 5 Advantages of Staying in a Sober Living House

Category

  • Business
  • Ecology
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Healthcare
  • Politics
  • Uncategorized

Recent News

FTC Building

FTC Cracks Down on Hidden Charges and “Junk Fees” in New Proposal

October 5, 2024
Eden Announces Extended Memorial Day Sale, Promoting Access to Metabolic Health Treatments

Eden Announces Extended Memorial Day Sale, Promoting Access to Metabolic Health Treatments

May 27, 2024
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

© 2022 parliamentobserver.com Submit news release

No Result
View All Result
  • Ecology
  • Economy
  • Healthcare
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Business

© 2022 parliamentobserver.com Submit news release

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In